It doesn’t matter
 whether our German brothers dub it a Golf or a Rabbit or a pine marten.
 What we have here, folks, is a winner with momentum. This is the eighth
 consecutive year that the VW Golf lineup, the lone GTI, or both have 
earned 10Best laurels. What Belushi and Aykroyd did for rumpled black 
suits, Volkswagen has done for hatchbacks.
Even
 the starter-kit five-door Golf automatic is a piquant stew of 
near-flawless fundamentals, and you can slide your cheeks into one for 
as little as $20,815. The TDI turbo-diesel is the Earth Firster’s happy 
hummer, a torque weasel that will make you feel marginally less guilty 
about climate change. With a manual shifter, a TDI five-door starts at 
$26,020. Both of these Golfs are gratifyingly balanced and composed if 
very different in acceleration. Their cabins are swathed in uplevel 
materials and pleasing surfaces. The unibody is a Mason jar of airtight 
rigidity. The suspension is unflustered by scabrous pavement. The 
steering’s effort builds naturally off-center. And the IP is dedicated 
to the serious minded.
As
 we’ve said several times before, the Golf remains an unlikely 
partnership of practicality and refinement. Rarely do economy cars so 
fervently reward precise inputs. Rarely has an econohatch been hobbled 
by so few compromises.
Of
 course, it’s the driver-focused GTI that is the wolf in Wolfsburg’s 
clothing. You can own a five-door manual Wolfsburg Edition GTI for only 
$25,915. This little comet still defines the hot-hatch class it created 
way back in 1976, and it still begs to be booted around like a hacky 
sack. The damper calibrations feel like the outcome of engineers who 
really care, with roll gorgeously controlled, yet the ride remains 
creamy and the brakes don’t fade.
The
 taut GTI glides to fame with one of automobiledom’s all-star 
drivelines: VW’s 200-hp, rev-happy, turbocharged 2.0-liter 
inline-four—with its delightful punch of midrange torque—mated to the 
optional paddle-shift dual-clutch DSG automatic ($1100). Never has plaid
 felt so fashionable or more happily been hustled. Drive it to the Home 
Depot on Saturday morning; enter an SCCA autocross at noon. How unlikely
 is it for a car this basic to feel so sophisticated, so mature, as if 
hatched in Munich or Ingolstadt? One C/D editor noted, “The GTI
 pours itself down the road, a fluid stream of disciplined control.” 
Okay, so that’s not exactly Faulkner, but we’re trying.
The
 GTI is not without pimples, of course. We still wish its clutch and 
brake pedals telegraphed slightly more info up the driver’s leg. On dry 
days with unlimited downrange visibility, we’d like to disable the 
traction control—completely. If it were up to us, we’d redact a
 smidgen of the existing understeer, and we’d also undertake all of our 
GTI motoring exclusively on summer tires, right until the moment that 
two snowflakes coalesce above.
It’s
 amazing that this sixth-gen Golf landed on 10Best again, because it’s 
what we call “almost over, not yet out.” The seventh-gen Golf—riding on 
the so-called MQB platform—will arrive this spring. It will be lighter, 
stronger, and longer by 2.2 inches, and in GTI spec, its engine should 
be at least 10 horses healthier. Note also that it will be assembled in 
Mexico for the first time since the third-gen cars. We’ve already 
sampled Euro-spec versions. They again seem likely to become the canny 
gray wolf that somehow gets dropped into a box of Labrador puppies—big 
toothsome bites of fun in a scary-good way. (That’s not Faulkner, 
either. More like the Columbus Zoo’s Jack Hanna.)